I sat down to write a top 10 list and came up with 200 albums. I got honest and maybe even cruel, and cut it down to 68. The numeric order gets more arbitrary as we proceed downward. I’m publishing this before I change my mind.
Has music writing turned into mere list-making? For me it sometimes has. I’ve written brilliant descriptions in my mind of why each of these are my favorites, but all I’ve managed are a few words describing each of the top 10.
I wrote very little about music in 2018. What’s the right metaphor for keeping up with all of the brilliant new music released every week, and then finding enough minutes to stop and write about it along the way? Something about a river or a waterfall, in a barrel or holding onto a twig. Or maybe it involves lava, a boiling pot, some other scientific phenomena? Rocks and hills? Weather? Traffic? Somebody find me the right words… (a mantra for 2018). Time marches on, there’s always next year, etc.
- Dear Nora – Skulls Example – Career-defining, and a brave step forward; projecting all of the environmental and social anxieties of the moment into a nexus of Southwest mysticism and bubblegum pop.
- Makaya McCraven – Universal Beings – Drummer-driven, like much of the best jazz and experimental music this year. But also collaborative and freeform; each of four sides connecting multiple cities, players and dynamic jazz scenes to build new connections and creations.
- Kacey Musgraves – Golden Hour – Country-pop taken in a sunlit, daydream, philosophical quandary direction. Filled with clever turns and breathtaking moments; it is possible still for an album to keep surprising.
- Rico Nasty – Nasty – A somewhat goofy Internet rapper transforms herself into the hardest and on-point rapper of the moment, projecting anger, humor, style and multiplicity.
- Meshell Ndegeocello – Ventriloquism – The best work of music criticism of the year, and non-stop pleasure to listen to. Recommended if you like ‘80s/’90s R&B, or have forgotten about it and need to go back.
- The Beths – Future Me Hates Me – Punkish pop-rock with a ‘90s sheen that nonetheless totally inhabits the current moment, via sharp-as-nails songwriting and self-deprecating humor that rides an amped-up guitar-pop wave like nobody’s business.
- Caitlyn Smith – Starfire – An accomplished songwriter steps into the spotlight, and dazzles, with show-stopping highway ballads and small-scale Waits/Hopper-esque scenes.
- SOB x RBE – Gangin II – The big splash from this youthful, hyper SoCal group began last year but picked up steadily in 2018, with the explosive Gangin’ and their Black Panther track “Paramedic!” Gangin II took all the fire of its predecessors and deepened the emotions and overall feel.
- Swamp Dogg – Love, Loss & Auto-Tune – Extending the Autotune-as-emotional-moisturizer approach of 808s and Heartbreak into every neck of the woods has become the life calling of Justin Vernon; here the eccentric soul legend Swamp Dogg wears that Autotune aesthetic remarkably well, through ‘futurized’ standards and more typical Swamp Dogg hijinks.
- Michael Nau & The Mighty Thread – Michael Nau & the Mighty Thread – The most tender rolling Americana melodicism of the year – lush and lovely in its melancholy exploration of wandering desert balladry.
- Ashley Monroe – Sparrow
- Peluché – Unforgettable
- Roy Kinsey – Blackie
- Arp – Zebra
- Boys – Rest in Peace
- Kamaal Williams – The Return
- Body/Head – The Switch
- Trouble and Mike Will Made-It – Edgewood
- Domineco Lancellotti – The Good Is a Big God
- Sons of Kemet – Your Queen Is a Reptile
- Nathan Bowles – Plainly Mistaken
- Let’s Eat Grandma – I’m All Ears
- Maisha – There Is a Place
- Tove Styrke – Sway
- Clay Hips – Happily Ever After
- CupcakKe – Ephorize
- Jerry David DeCicca – Time the Teacher
- Beach House – 7
- Dorian Concept – The Nature of Imitation
- Pistol Annies – Interstate Gospel
- Noname – Room 25
- The Goon Sax – We’re Not Talking
- Jennifer Castle – Angels of Death
- Fred Thomas – Aftering
- Tres Oui – Poised to Flourish
- Of Montreal – White Is Relic/Irrealis Mood
- Booker Stardrum – Temporary, etc.
- Khruangbin – Con Todo El Mundo
- Jonathan Richman – SA
- Migos – Culture II
- Drinks – Hippo Lite
- Chloe x Halle – The Kids Are Alright
- Massage – Oh Boy
- Meg Baird and Mary Lattimore – Ghost Forests
- Serpentwithfeet – Soil Reprise
- DJ Muggs X Roc Marciano – Kaos
- Jack Hayter – Abbey Wood
- Chris Crofton – Hello It’s Me
- Say Sue Me – Where We Were Together
- Pete Astor – One for the Ghost
- Yo La Tengo – There’s a Riot Going On
- Low – Double Negative
- Tunde Olaniran – Stranger
- The Ocean Party – The Oddfellows’ Hall
- Cloud – Plays With Fire
- Jay Rock – Redemption
- Eleanor Friedberger – Rebound
- Slim Jxmi – Jxmtro
- Frankie Cosmos – Vessel
- FaceFace – MMmm
- Anna Burch – Quit the Curse
- Benjamin Shaw – Megadead
- The Spook School – Could It Be Different?
- Smokescreens – Used to Yesterday
- Laura Gibson – Goners
- Sarah Davachi – Let Night Come On Bells End The Day
- Yhung T.O. – Trust Issues
- Landing – Bells in New Towns
Happy new year! Yours truly,
Dave